American Coney...Downtown D.

American Coney Island!

Lafayette, downtown!

Coney roll at sportsmens on fort st. Nowhere else can touch it.

Only lived here a few months so the only coney I've had is Leo's. Coney tour would open up a new world for me :)

nothing beats Lipuma's in Rochester!!! If you don't like a coney, there are numerous other "dog" options, the best servers behind a grill, and scenic seating on Paint Creek

Lafayette and leo's are great - when I moved here from Virginia did not think I would find a place that would be better than our local chain in Va called "the daug house" but to my surprise I did!

Leo's Coney Island

Leo's coney island

Greek Isles

Leo's

LAFAYETTE is the best. I am 67 years old and LAFAYETTE is truly a learning experience....especially if you go there around midnight. The first time I went there, I was dating a guy and he dared me that I could not eat a LAFAYETTE without getting it on my face or spilling it on the plate. I WON!!!! I loved Nemo when he made a quarter stay on his forhead and then would give me a hug. I doesn't matter if you are rich, poor, government official or bum EVERYONE has fun at LAFAYETTE. I raised 5 children and ALL of them know: "If you go to LAFAYETTE you better bring Mom back one (or two).

leo's coney island

If you are going to do Coney - you need to do Leo's. It is a family affair - our kids are now 22 and 24 and are still die hard fans.

Lafayette, it's a tradition. However , American and Lafayette now have the same dogs, just different in the mixture. It comes down to the chili sauce you like.

Lafayette Coney Island is my favorite. I remember a good friend had her 85 Birthday Party at the Coney Island. It was purchased by her daughter and the Coney Island was closed for the evening, a Sunday. It was a suprise birthday Party for her and about fifty people showed up.the Coneys are the greatest.

My favorite is lafayette, ever since the time I was walking by and turned by the shoulders toward the door by the owner who told me I was hungry..k. Collins

I know the Detroit battle, but for me, the best is Bill's in Ypsilanti. Root beer is cold, dogs are good, chili is homemade and onions are spicy.

Lafayette lives up to it's hype. If I move from Detroit, I would miss the Detroit style coneys.

Lafatette Coney Island is a metro Detroit area legend and serves up the best coneys I've ever had.

Lafayette Coney island is by far the nest

Leo's of Lake Orion, newly remodeled, clean, great food and service ... the best is that it is walking distance from our home and we can just get our daily walk while enjoy eating at one of our favorite eateries in Lake Orion.

Lafayette is the winner

Lafayette is my fav - hands down! But I can't turn down a coney from anywhere. :) Used to live out of state and I missed being able to get a real Detroit coney!

Lipuma's in Rochester. Hands down the greatest coneys with the most interesting choices.

Lafayette is the Best

PAK
Senates Coney Island in Northville has the best coney's around.

Lipumas in Rochester is awesome.

Lafayette, when I was a kid my father would take the family there, it was a real treat because we didn't have alot money

Lafayette for sure. never a dull moment and everyone is so friendly. Jane Plieth

Lipumas in Rochester

Another Vote for Senate Coney Island, been going to SCI since the original was still on Michigan Avenue near Martin. Hometown local Dave's Coney at Bogie Lake Rd gets my second place vote and Lipumas gets a very well deserved "Honorable Mention" :-)

Leo's is terrible. Lafayette hands down.

National Coney Island. Great chili. Lipuma's is awesome too.

We have our winners. We'll be contacting winners now via email. Thanks for entering!

National Coney Island - hands down!!!!